L4M1-LO1-1: Working with Suppliers in Complex Supply Chains – Case Study

Case Study: Orion Motors and Its Global Supply Chain

Orion Motors is a car manufacturing company (OEM).
The company assembles vehicles but relies on a global network of suppliers for engines, electronics, and materials.

Orion Motors:

  • Receives complete engines from one main supplier

  • Buys electronic systems from another supplier

  • Does not manufacture parts or raw materials itself

The engine supplier depends on other organisations:

  • One supplies engine components

  • Another supplies fuel systems

  • Others provide metals and raw materials

Orion Motors has contracts only with suppliers that deliver directly to it.
Recently, the company experienced delivery delays, quality issues, and concerns about ethical labour practices within its supply chain.


Questions and Guided Explanations

Question 1

Which supplier is closest to Orion Motors, and why?

Answer and Explanation

The supplier that delivers engines directly to Orion Motors is the closest supplier.
This supplier is known as a Tier 1 supplier.

Supply chain tiering groups suppliers by their distance from the buyer:

  • Tier 1 supplies directly to the OEM

  • Tier 2 supplies to Tier 1

  • Tier 3 supplies raw materials

The lower the tier number, the closer the supplier is to the buyer.


Question 2

Why does Orion Motors not deal directly with companies producing engine parts and raw materials?

Answer and Explanation

These companies supply parts to the engine supplier, not to Orion Motors.

They are:

  • Tier 2 suppliers (component suppliers)

  • Tier 3 suppliers (raw material suppliers)

This structure allows Orion Motors to:

  • Manage fewer suppliers

  • Focus on key relationships

  • Reduce administrative effort

This is one of the main benefits of supply chain tiering.


Question 3

How could suppliers in lower tiers affect Orion Motors, even without direct contact?

Answer and Explanation

If a Tier 2 supplier fails to deliver parts, the Tier 1 supplier cannot assemble engines.
This leads to delays for Orion Motors.

This shows that:

  • Issues in lower tiers can still impact the buyer

  • Distance in the supply chain does not remove risk

Complex supply chains increase dependency across all tiers.


Question 4

Why did Orion Motors struggle to identify ethical labour issues in its supply chain?

Answer and Explanation

Orion Motors focuses mainly on Tier 1 suppliers and has limited visibility beyond them.

Lower-tier suppliers:

  • Are harder to monitor

  • Operate in different regions

  • Are often managed indirectly

This increases the risk of:

  • Ethical breaches

  • Sustainability failures

  • Legal non-compliance


Question 5

What role does auditing play in managing Orion Motors’ supply chain?

Answer and Explanation

Auditing involves formal inspections to ensure suppliers meet required standards.

For Orion Motors:

  • Audits are easier to conduct at Tier 1 level

  • Lower tiers are more difficult to audit due to distance and complexity

However, effective supply chain management requires the OEM to:

  • Extend audits beyond Tier 1 where possible

  • Use Tier 1 suppliers to support auditing of lower tiers

  • Ensure all suppliers follow ethical, legal, and sustainability standards

Auditing helps reduce risk and improve accountability across the supply chain.


Question 6

How could supply chain mapping support auditing and risk control?

Answer and Explanation

Supply chain mapping shows:

  • All suppliers

  • Their tier positions

  • Their locations and relationships

This allows Orion Motors to:

  • Identify high-risk suppliers

  • Target audits more effectively

  • Improve transparency across tiers

Mapping makes auditing more structured and manageable.


Question 7

Why is Orion Motors’ supply chain described as complex rather than linear?

Answer and Explanation

Suppliers often:

  • Work with multiple manufacturers

  • Supply different products

  • Operate across several countries

This creates a network, not a straight line.

Understanding the supply chain as a network:

  • Improves strategic oversight

  • Supports better auditing and risk management

  • Reflects real-world supply chain operations


Question 8

Who is responsible for ensuring ethical and legal compliance across all tiers?

Answer and Explanation

Although suppliers operate at different tiers, the OEM holds overall responsibility.

Orion Motors must:

  • Set clear standards

  • Conduct and support audits

  • Ensure compliance throughout the supply chain

This reduces exposure to ethical, legal, and reputational risks.


Key Learning from the Case Study

  • Supply chain tiering organises suppliers by proximity to the buyer

  • Tier 1 suppliers are closest and easiest to manage

  • Lower tiers increase complexity and risk

  • Auditing is essential but more challenging beyond Tier 1

  • Supply chain mapping improves visibility and audit effectiveness

  • Real supply chains operate as complex networks