Learning objective
Understand why the lowest price is not always the most cost-effective choice.
The case
Najd Fresh Foods, a fictional Saudi dairy manufacturer, needs a new labelling machine. Without correct labels, finished products cannot leave the packaging line.
Ahmed, a new Assistant Buyer, receives two acceptable offers:
-
Supplier A: SAR 70,000
-
Supplier B: SAR 86,000
Ahmed is ready to recommend Supplier A because it is SAR 16,000 cheaper. Before approving the recommendation, Sarah, the Chief Procurement Officer, asks him to speak with the production and maintenance teams.
They explain that Supplier A imports its spare parts and may need up to three working days to respond to a major breakdown. Supplier B keeps essential parts and technicians in Riyadh and commits to respond within eight working hours.
Using maintenance records, warranty information and supplier references, the team estimates that Supplier A could cause around 25 hours of production stoppage over three years, compared with five hours for Supplier B.
Najd Fresh Foods estimates that every stopped hour costs about SAR 1,000 through lost production, employee waiting time, overtime and delayed deliveries. This period of stopped operations is called downtime.
Sarah and Ahmed discuss the offers
Ahmed: Supplier A is cheaper, but production is concerned about breakdowns and slow support.
Sarah: What happens financially when the machine stops?
Ahmed: The packaging line stops. Employees wait, production is lost and deliveries may be delayed.
Sarah: Can we estimate that impact?
Ahmed: Yes. Production values each stopped hour at about SAR 1,000.
Sarah: What downtime do they expect from each supplier?
Ahmed: Twenty-five hours for Supplier A and five hours for Supplier B over three years.
Sarah: Why is the difference so large?
Ahmed: Supplier A imports its parts and responds within three days. Supplier B has local parts and an eight-hour response commitment.
Sarah: Then calculate the downtime cost.
Ahmed: Supplier A is 25 hours multiplied by SAR 1,000, giving SAR 25,000. Supplier B is five hours multiplied by SAR 1,000, giving SAR 5,000.
Sarah: Now include purchase and maintenance costs.
Ahmed: Supplier A reaches SAR 125,000, while Supplier B reaches SAR 103,000.
Sarah: What does that tell you?
Ahmed: Supplier A is cheaper to buy, but Supplier B is expected to cost SAR 22,000 less over three years.
Sarah: Good. Before recommending Supplier B, confirm the service commitments, spare-parts availability and reliability of our estimates.
Cost comparison
| Cost | Supplier A | Supplier B |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | SAR 70,000 | SAR 86,000 |
| Maintenance | SAR 30,000 | SAR 12,000 |
| Downtime | SAR 25,000 | SAR 5,000 |
| Three-year total | SAR 125,000 | SAR 103,000 |
The figures are fictional and used for learning. In practice, downtime estimates should be supported by maintenance records, supplier references, response times and the organisation’s cost per stopped hour.
Sarah’s conclusion
Sarah: “Cost-effective procurement does not mean automatically choosing the cheapest or the most expensive offer. Start with the result required, compare the full cost of each acceptable option and confirm the evidence behind your estimates. The best decision is the option that achieves the required outcome at the most reasonable overall cost and risk.”
Key knowledge
-
Cost-effective means achieving the required result through the best reasonable use of resources.
-
Downtime is the period when equipment is unavailable and operations stop.
-
Downtime cost can be estimated as:
Downtime hours × cost per stopped hour
-
A higher purchase price may be justified by lower maintenance, faster support or reduced operational disruption.
-
Cost differences must be supported by evidence, not assumptions.